Cookie Exchange Ideas

One of the best things about the holiday season is all the yummy treats! ‘Tis the season for baking and candy-making and cookie exchanges. If you’ve been invited to a cookie exchange party and need some cookie swap ideas, look no further. Find tips about how to choose the perfect recipe, when to make your cookies, and how to package them.

Cookie Exchange Ideas

Here are some helpful ideas for cookie exchange creativity and etiquette, which will help you know what to expect:

  • Share A Favorite Recipe: Do you have a family recipe that has been passed down through the generations? Or maybe you have your own cookie creation that others simply swoon over every time you bake them. One of the best cookie exchange ideas is to share your most popular baked goody. Don’t hold anything back! You’ll impress the other guests and they will thank you for sharing the pièce de résistance.
  • Bake Them Fresh: There are two very important ideas for cookie swap preparation that you need to keep in mind when you’re planning for the cookie exchange party. The holidays may be hectic, but it’s essential that you make your cookies fresh either the day before or the day of the event. Homemade goods can dry out quickly and nobody wants to eat a stale cookie. Here’s an insider tip: an apple wedge placed inside your cookie container can boost freshness. Just be sure to replace it every day. It’s also important to be aware of any allergies that the other guests may have. Don’t share your great aunt’s famed peanut butter drop cookies if they are going to cause one of the fellow guests to drop!
  • Package Them Prettily: Some wrapping ideas for cookie exchange party include mason jars, decorative Chinese food containers, wicker baskets, or traditional round tins. Tie a holiday ribbon around the packaging or affix a cheery Christmas bow. Include a card with the recipe (if you’re willing to share) and a note saying whose kitchen they came from.

Now swap ‘til you drop! What’s the final tip for this list of Christmas cookie swap ideas? Have fun! You’re sure to go home with a bundle of sweets and some new ideas to try out in the kitchen. Hosting the exchange tthis year? Send one of our FREE cookie exchange invitations!  

Free Cookie Exchange invitations

free Christmas invitations

Envelope Icon Love this article?

Sign up and we'll send more inspiration straight to you.

Sign up now